h1

Is Instructional Design the Right Career?

June 20, 2007

This is the last installment of my series on instructional design careers. Links to the rest of the series are at the end of this post. Previously, I’ve talked about the skills instructional designers need and about ideas for finding a job. In this post I want to talk about figuring out if instructional design is a good “fit” as a career. This is less about the skills and more about the desire; it’s about figuring out if someone would be happy working as an instructional designer.

Working Behind the Scenes

In one of my former jobs, I interviewed a lot of candidates for instructional designer openings. A fair number of these candidates were teachers who wanted to change careers, and we always asked those candidates how they would feel not having direct interaction with students. That’s one of the important considerations for teachers and trainers who are used to being up in front of a room full of people. If you’re thinking about a career in instructional design, ask yourself: will I be happy working “behind the scenes” instead of directly with students? If the answer is no, then maybe this isn’t the right fit for you. Of course, there are positions that combine instructional design with student interaction; Wendy Wickham does everything.

Working with SMEs

Working “behind the scenes” doesn’t mean you don’t work with people though. Building relationships with Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) is an important part of what we do as well. Knowing how to work with content experts and guide them through the course development process is crucial. Every organization has different expectations for how IDs and SMEs work together, but this is often a close collaborative relationship. If you hate having someone else act as the expert, you probably won’t enjoy being an ID; our job is to be experts on designing the learning, (usually) not experts in the content.

Learning & Using Technology

I won’t belabor the point about technology skills again here since I’ve posted about it previously. However, if you really dislike learning new technology, instructional design probably isn’t a good career fit. Of course, I think everyone in every job needs to learn how to learn at least some technology, but that’s a larger conversation on lifelong learning and literacy.

Always Learning

One of my favorite parts of being an instructional designer is that I am always learning something new. That seems to be a common characteristic of instructional designers; we see the opportunity to continuously learn as a benefit of the job.

Helping Others Learn

To feel fulfilled in a career as an instructional designer, I think you have to enjoy helping people learn. I personally prefer working in the education field because I feel like I am making a difference. Even software training can make people’s lives better in a small way though. The best instructional designers I’ve worked with have been excited by figuring out ways to create great learning experiences. Technology gets us motivated because of the opportunities for learning it creates; design methods and research are tools that make us more effective. Everything revolves around helping people learn. More than anything else, I think that desire to help others learn is what drives the best instructional designers.

If you’re someone considering a career in instructional design, I hope this series has given you some insight on what we do, how we do it, and why we like it.

Other Posts in this Series

  1. What Does an Instructional Designer Do?
  2. Getting Into Instructional Design
  3. Instructional Design Skills
  4. Technology Skills
  5. Professional Organizations and Career Options
  6. Is Instructional Design the Right Career? (current post)

Update: Read all my posts about Instructional Design Careers here.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

35 comments

  1. Thank you for your insight into this new field for me. I’ve been an ELL teacher for 10 years and now am thinking expanding my horizons. All of the criteria you mentioned fit me to a T. I love learning and am excited to think of the possibilities in a different line of work. I’ll still teach while working on my Master’s Program in Instructional Design so I won’t be missing the children quite yet.


  2. Hi Jody,

    I’m glad you found this helpful. After seeing several of your posts on the eLearning Guild forums, I thought this series would have good information for you. You have been asking a lot of great questions, and I’m guessing you’ll come up with more questions as you get further into your master’s program.

    When I first left teaching for corporate training, I taught Sunday school so I still had some interaction with kids. That helped me with the transition. If you have some way to volunteer to work with kids for even an hour or two a week after you stop teaching, I think that can be very helpful.

    Keep asking all those great questions!


  3. could you help me in finding an university to do my diploma in instructional design from Singapore or if not from any other country.
    thanking you for your precious information shared with us.
    waiting for a quick reply.


  4. i need to find an university to do my diploma in instructional design. could you lend a helping hand.
    i think i need to do it in Singapore. if not its ok from any other country.
    by the way thank you for sharing


  5. I don’t know of any programs in Singapore, but there are several 100% online degrees available. I’ve heard good reviews of Indiana University in Bloomington, San Diego State University, and Bloomsburg University in Pennsylvania. There’s a good post on Tony Karrer’s blog with a number of suggestions for online programs in the comments. I’m more familiar with the US programs, but several of the replies to Tony were for schools in the UK or Canada that might work for you.


  6. I found these posts to be invauable as well as insightful. After teaching secondary English for almost ten years, I became burned out so I became certified to teach elementary school. Teaching fourth grade is a refreshing change and I am enjoying it. However, I eventually want to become an instructional designer. I just hope I can find a full time job and make more money than I do teaching…I’ll hopefully graduate next spring. I am considering a move to a city that has a strong IT field and plentiful instructional design jobs. I would love to hear from current ISDs to gain a better insight. I love being creative as well as teaching…I have average technology skills, but I am learnig a lot in my Master’s program (only 1/3 of the way done)… I need some encouragement folks! Hope to hear from you.

    David


  7. Thank you so much for the kind words, and I’m very happy to hear that this information was valuable to you. I certainly understand feeling burnt out from teaching. You’ve lasted much longer than I did!

    Where are you doing your masters program? Are there areas or topics you’re finding to be especially challenging in the program?
    Do you have a blog where you could share your experiences? I’ve gotten several requests for information on masters programs in ID, so I know people would be interested in learning more (including me). Maybe interacting with people through a blog could give you some of the encouragement you need too.


  8. Hi,

    I am based in India and am working as an Instructional Designer for the last 3 years. I have done a 6 month certification in Instrutional Designing through a distance learning program from one of the institutes in India itself.

    What is my chance of getting the job of an instructional designer in the US? Is my experience in the field alongwith the certification sufficient for me to secure a job in the same profile in the US.

    Any guidance or suggestion will be highly appreciated.

    Thanks


  9. Kamal,

    Unfortunately, I don’t have any personal experience with H1-B visas or people moving to the US for jobs. I have worked with some great Indian instructional designers, but they were all based in Mumbai and Bangalore. I do know that a number of job listings specify that they are unable to sponsor visas, so that does make it more difficult.

    That said, your prior experience and certification are both assets. If you haven’t already joined LinkedIn to start networking, I recommend doing so. Even if everyone you’re directly connected to is in India, your second- and third-level connections might be in the US. Try posting your resume on the eLearning Guild job board too; that’s how I found my current job.

    Creating an online portfolio would also help set you apart from others in the field (including me!). That would be a great way to demonstrate that quality of your work.


  10. Hi Christy,

    Thanks a lot for your guidance. I really appreciate you taking the time to respond to my queries. I will follow your suggestion and keep my fingers crossed for something to work out.

    Thanks again :-)
    Kamal


  11. I found the information to be of real help to me as I am also thinking of shifting from teachin to ID. Will I be able to get into this field with 8 yrs of teaching experience? Thank you for all the explanation about ID,especially to a beginner like me. I would like to know about training programmes in ID given by Indian institutes.


  12. 8 years of teaching experience on its own without any specific instructional learning (formal or informal) might not be enough. The teaching experience is beneficial, certainly, but it isn’t enough on its own. Completing a training program, as you mentioned, would be an excellent idea though.

    Unfortunately, I’m not at all familiar with programs in India. You might try some of the Indian instructional design blogs; they would be more likely to have the information you need.

    Rupa at One Stop Resource for Instructional Designing
    Manish at Life, the Universe, and Everything about Learning and Content Development
    eCube, a group blog


  13. Hi, Christy. Read all of your posts on Instructional Design and loved them. I am currently enrolled in a Master’s degree program in Educational Technology at Webster University in St. Louis, Missouri. The person who was asking about taking a course in Singapore on instructional design might check out http://www.webster.edu I am mainly taking classes that require going to campus, but this degree could also be done on-line as well, and I know there are people in it from around the world. Webster also has worldwide campuses.

    All the terms you referred to are ones I will be learning. I want to be a corporate trainer. Have done technical writing and training, and am an SME, but have never been given the formal title or credit for it. The skills needed are also ones I have taken or will be taking – Photoshop, Desktop Publishing, Instructional Design, Flash, etc.

    One comment on ASTD. Became a member once and attended several meetings. Did not feel comfortable with this group. Unless you are among the top-ranked in this field my gut feeling was they don’t value you as much. They also changed all their meetings to the daytime, which I cannot make.


  14. Thanks for the suggestion of Webster, Jean. It sounds like you are getting experience with a lot of practical applications in your program.

    I’d never heard of ASTD having that kind of attitude. I wonder if that was an issue with the particular chapter in your area or if it’s more widespread. I have much more personal experience with the e-Learning Guild, but I do know that people have had positive experiences with other ASTD chapters. Daytime meetings can be hard; when I did corporate training, I could never attend them either.

    Perhaps the St. Louis chapter of ISPI would be a better fit for you. It might be worth checking out.


  15. Thanks a ton for this informative post. I am a corporate trainer who develops a lot of content. I was planning on taking a course on ID so that I have professional certification and also learn some of the theory in ID that I am not aware of.
    Your post has strenghtened my resolve that the course will be helpfull


  16. @Prabha, I’m glad this post was helpful. Where are you planning to take your ID course? I’ve had people ask me before about training programs, but I’m not really familiar enough with anything outside the US to direct anyone to good programs. I’d love to know where you’re going to get your certification and why you chose that particular program.


  17. I have done 2 month course in ID but couldnt join the ID field due to my previous business which i could not leave its about 1 year 2 months since the course has been done. I participated well liked the course have been certified as ID. Can i join this field now? If so what can i expect as Salary In India or abroad? I have PG as education qualification. Would like your replies in my mail.
    Have other queries need your personel guidance.


  18. I am planning to pursue masters in instructional technology. I have no experience in teaching but i have been working as a graphic designer for over 3 years.
    Do you think this is the right program for me?


  19. If instructional technology is what you’re passionate about and you’re happy with the program, then it’s probably the right choice. Honestly, I don’t feel like I have anywhere near enough information about you to make a judgment about whether the program is right for you or not. There’s simply too many variables: your learning style, your goals for your career, the balance in your life, the quality of the program…

    Even if I knew all those variables, I wouldn’t be comfortable giving more than a suggestion or recommendation. Ultimately, I think that has to be a personal decision.


  20. Hi Christy,

    The information you provided is valuable. I am a seasoned instructional designer and currently working as a Project Manager in the Learning & Development division of an MNC. It is very unfortunate that in India, many univiersities do not have a formal degree program in ID. However, for those who are really interested in making a career in ID, I would personally recommend the two year master’s degree program in Educational Technology offered by SNDT Women’s University in Mumbai. Please contact det@sndt.ac.in for further details.

    Regards,
    Ram


  21. hi , i like to do ID, please guide me where can i do this in india, by post (distance education)


  22. Hi Christy,

    Thank you so much for the valuable information about ID. I have not planned my career as an ID so for.. But i happened to get an offer as ID in an MNC.. i have finished my UG and diploma in Multimedia ( includes photo editing and video softwares ) and Diploma in Maya animation and web designing and development.. but i dont have any experience in any job till date.. i had my own business ( photo studio ) where i used to work only on photoshop and adobe premiere..
    Basically i am an artist.. i do variety of paintings ( oil,actylic, glass and traditional paintings of india ).. I also have passion for teaching students though not experienced..
    I love learning a lot…
    Do all these qualifications of mine are enough to be as an ID in that company.. they gave an offer only as a trainee in ID for 2 months and i have to start doing of my own from the third month.

    What are the other things i have to concentrate to be a successful ID?
    I would love to have your suggessions or advices.

    akila.


  23. Hi Christy,

    One more question is that.. will they teach me from the day one everything about ID?
    It is a company which develops ebooks or elearning tools for k-12 students.
    After reading lots of information om ID i love to be an ID in that company.. but want to improvise myself for that.. thatz why i am in need of your suggessions.

    Thanks,
    Akila.


  24. Hi ,

    Just wanted to know what abo’ those who would like to start an ID career now? I am already working but as a programmer but signed up for the wavelength course for IDs.. awaiting my cerfs.. but wanted a inside info on would companies be willing to recruit someone with just a cerf on ID? What would be the basic requisities to be added to a resume before searchign for ID jobs?.Any help would be great!

    Regards,
    Divya


    • @Divya, whether you can get a job as an ID with just a certificate probably depends on your prior experience. If you’re looking for something that covers the entire instructional design cycle, then employers will look for writing experience and experience developing training materials. Manish Mohan explains, “But honestly, as a manager who has had to recruit for ID, I look for prior experience, and if there is no prior experience, I look for their core writing skills and ability to learn.”

      Because your background is as a programmer though, I wonder if you might find it easier to break into the field as an instructional developer, focusing on the technical aspects of Flash programming & multimedia development for content designed by others.

      You might also look at the posts in response to this month’s Learning Circuits Big Question on new skills for learning professionals for other skills to help you get a job.


  25. Im working in a MNC as ID, currently i have 1.5 years experiance, i wish to be in the company for more than 3 years, currently im drawing 1.7lks P.A,
    what will be my salary after 2 years.


    • I’m afraid I can’t help too much with salary information in India. However, I can point you to someone with much more knowledge in this area: Manish Mohan. He’s conducting his unofficial e-learning salary survey right now. You can also look at the results from the last two years.


  26. This is a fantastic series, thank you so much! I’ve been teaching ESL for the last 12 years, and some of my experience in the field has been related to online learning. I am quite interested in pursuing ID, and your articles have been such a help. Thank you! :)


  27. Hey Christy!

    Sooooo glad I came across your blog. Very excited. I finally know what to call and how to pursue the career I’ve known for some time was my ‘calling’. ID is exactly what I want to do and this blog is really helpful for someone who, like myself, needs a little push in the right direction. Thank you.


  28. Hi

    Thanks a lot. I found the info extremely useful. I am into technical writing for almost 2 years and have enjoyed this field. I am looking to become a highly skilled instructional designer and always look for useful resources.

    Thanks again.


  29. hai,
    I would like to join as instructional designer in some E-learning companies.but i don’t know how to search jobs in that field.
    can you please help me out in searching jobs in that field?.thank you


    • Priya, I’m mostly familiar with the US job search sites. You could certainly look at the eLearning Guild; that might have some international jobs. It looks like by your email address that you’re in India, so check out the directory of elearning providers in India from eCube. Manish Mohan is a great resource for e-learning info; you might try asking him to point you in the right direction.


  30. Hi Christy-

    Thank you for this insightful information.

    I am currently a grad student in the Instructional Design and Technology field at Walden University. For many years, I struggled with what I wanted to be “when I grew up”. After several years in the workforce, I found a job as an administrative assistant at a community college. I found that I love the field of education, so much so, that I decided to go back to school. I first finished my associate degree in 2006, my bachelor degree this past August (09), and started on a M.S. this past September (09). Like you, I enjoy learning new things.

    The turning point for me, when I decided that I really wanted to stay in the field of education, was when I was asked to develop training material for a new ERP software application our college implemented. I really enjoyed developing the training material, and I enjoyed conducting one-on-one training with fellow employees. That is when the light bulb went on, so to speak, and I found the direction I wanted to go with my career.

    As I read your post, it further confirmed that I am in the right field for me. I love learning and technology, and I love helping others learn new things. As an administrative assistant, I always work behind the scenes, and that is where I prefer to be.

    In this article, you mention the need for continuous learning in the instructional design field. It would seem that continuous learning is fast becoming a requirement of many fields. My husband has worked in the information technology field for a decade. That field also requires continuous learning. I have also found, through my own experiences, that even the office administration field requires continuous learning. As Henry Ford said, “Anyone who stops learning is old, whether at twenty or eighty” (Quote Garden, 2009).

    Thank you again for the insightful information.

    Reference:

    Quote Garden. (2009). Quotations about learning. Retrieved November 8, 2009, from http://www.quotegarden.com/learning.html.


    • I definitely agree that lifelong learning is a requirement for every field. It used to be that you could graduate, get a job, and never have to do major retraining for the rest of your career. But the world changes too fast for that now. There is just more to learn in every field.

      I think that’s actually a good sign for the future of instructional design though; people clearly will continue to need learning, maybe even more than in the past. We have to work to keep ourselves relevant, of course, and I don’t think that everything we do will continue to be discrete courses, but there are ample opportunities for creating and supporting learning.

      I do, however, think that instructional designers spend more of their time learning than people in most other fields. We have to be good at picking up content quickly and without great materials, since we’re the ones making those great learning experiences. Instructional designers have to be more responsible for their own self-directed learning.



Leave a Comment